About the Book
Contrary to the impression conveyed by current media coverage, legalization is actually not the central issue regarding assisted suicide. The debate is about sanctioning a current, albeit limited, practice. The debate is about removing criminal prohibitions, not about initiating a practice. Assisted suicide is practiced now regardless of its illegality. The truly important questions are about whether suicide ever makes good sense, whether assisting suicide is ever permissible, and if so, what professional ethics should govern its provision.
Like abortion, assisted suicide raises questions that pose profound moral, social, and political dilemmas. Effective ethical guidance for assisted suicide is not lacking for want of effort: it is lacking because of conflict and dissent. Arguments about it arise from a class of divergent conceptions of personal autonomy and the nature of human life. The hard fact that assisted suicide is practiced regardless of its legality makes questions about the ethics that govern it pressing.
Prado and Taylor aim to enable compromise between ethical theoreticians and clinicians about the provision of assisted suicide by clarifying what is most at issue in their argument. Prado and Taylor do not agree: one spends his working time pondering epistemological questions and the other spends her working time forging ethical answers. Their collaboration results in a constructive exploration of the issue of assisted suicide.